COLOUR WITH CLAIRE
  • ~Home~
  • ~My Story~
  • ~Mental Health~
  • ~Beginner's Guide to Colouring~
  • ~Tutorials~
  • ~Colouring Book Reviews~
  • ~Product Reviews~
  • ~Arts & Crafts Reviews~
  • ~Gallery~
  • ~Colouring Challenges~
  • ~Gemstones~
  • ~Charts~
  • ~Digital Painting~
  • ~Illustrator Interviews~
  • ~Media Appearances~
  • ~FAQ~
  • ~Contact~
  • ~Policy~
  • Palette generator

Ultimate Sharpeners!

10/10/2015

19 Comments

 
Picture
As all colourists know, decent coloured pencils cost a substantial amount of money. It's so disheartening to finally have some beautiful pencils to work with, only to find they need sharpening every five minutes and have breakages left right and centre. Before long, you're left with this:
Picture
©Jim Leggitt
Prismacolor pencils are especially notorious for sharpening down to nothing very quickly, which is not good considering how much we shell out for them! Well, I'm here to save the day with a comparison of some excellent sharpeners that are on the market at the moment, some well known and others that you might not have heard of. 

First of all, a sharpener who's name has been floating around as one of the best- KUM automatic long point.

Picture
The German-made KUM sharpener features a 2-hole sharpening system; one for sharpening the wood and the other to sharpen the lead to a long point. It has an automatic brake which will stop sharpening once it has reached the optimum length. Whilst I got a decent enough point from the first hole, when trying the second I found it made no difference at all. I tried changing the blade (you are given 2 spares) but it was the same result. From reviews online, this is something that only happens to the minority of users, because generally this sharpener is highly regarded. As you can see, there's not much of a difference at all apart from the wood looks rougher, as if a layer has been taken off the top. Whilst I can't personally vouch for this sharpener with my experience of it, the overwhelmingly positive reviews online tell me that I've probably got a defective product with blunted blades. I'd love to hear your thoughts if you own this.
Picture
Picture


EDIT: I decided to give the KUM sharpener one last try with the second spare blade and guess what? Super long sharp points! I've heard a lot about dull blades straight off the production line with this brand, so if you have one of these I would definitely test all your blades and contact KUM if they're blunt.

Picture
DUX is another German company who have specialised in making exceptional quality sharpeners for over 100 years. This adjustable sharpener is made from solid brass and presented in a leather case, giving it a professional and expensive feel. By twisting the knurl at the end, the blade's grip on the pencil is tightened or loosened, producing 3 different tip lengths from blunted to fine. All 3 settings produce a similar length, but the third is particularly sharp. It's when you look at the length of the pencil that you see the difference in how much you've actually taken off.
Picture
Picture
Picture
As you can see, the pencil on the highest setting is noticeably shorter than the one on the lowest, yet the points are fairly similar. It is this adjustment mechanism that I am most excited about, because it means that it's now possible to get a sharp point on your pencil without sacrificing length, therefore giving it a longer life. This brings me onto the next two sharpeners which are of Japanese manufacture and are the best I've found so far.

Picture
Picture
Made by the same duo of companies, these next two sharpeners are wonderful- yet there's still one that outperforms the other. The K'ZOOL has 5 different point settings from short to long, the rotatable wheel changing the angle of the blade to vary the lead length. There's also a handy button at the centre which will eject any stuck leads from the blade area, and a removable hatch for you to empty the sharpenings.
Picture
Picture

The final sharpener I have to show you is in my mind the best, not only out of these four but that I've ever used. The T'GAAL.
It produces the most noticeable contrast in the pencils, with the number 1 setting exhibiting minimal wood loss and a short, sharp point. This ability to retain as much pencil as possible whilst still having a needle sharp point is what will end up saving your pencils and making them last as long as they possibly can. I'll be sharpening all my pencils on setting 1 or 2 with the T'GAAL- just look at the difference in length loss across the board!
Picture
Picture

I hope I've been able to give an insight into the world of professional sharpeners. None of the ones I've shown you today created any breakages or loose points, even on their longest and sharpest settings. If you have any questions or thoughts, as always I'm eager to hear them!

Here are links to all the sharpeners I've reviewed today along with their prices as of 10/10/15. Free delivery on all orders over £10, just £1.50 shipping on anything else.


Kum Automatic Long Point Sharpener AS2, £2.,79
Dux Adjustable Brass Pencil Sharpener, £13.99

Kutsuwa Stad KZool Pencil Sharpener, £2.50
Kutsuwa Stad T'Gaal Adjustable Pencil Sharpener, £6.98

I was given these products in exchange for an honest review.
Picture
19 Comments
Anita McQueen
10/10/2015 11:17:39 pm

Thanks.. this is really helpful... I am just starting out and I have found this to be a big help. Very appreciated.

Reply
Twana
11/10/2015 01:01:31 am

Thanks for this review!

Reply
Michelle Wadeson
11/10/2015 01:11:52 pm

Thank you Claire very much for this awesome review - very helpful. I am going try your recommendation. It will be great to have a sharpener that does not chew through my pencils. Investing in pencils like Derwent Studio and or Prismacolor Verithins for detail and texture is good as they have harder leads - then you don't have to continue sharpening your colouring pencils (Polychromos/Prismacolor) to a sharp point all the time.

Reply
Barb Stachow link
15/11/2015 07:30:04 pm

Claire , Verathins are not really for coloring in large spaces, they are for areas where a person wants to have definite hard pencil color, like eyes or around the lips as you would lip liner for example. :)

Reply
Claire
15/11/2015 11:07:25 pm

Hi, these are Premier not Verithin. "Verithin tend to be harder, making them more suitable for detailed work. Prismacolor are medium on the soft-hard scale, much like other pencils, and are suitable for both broad and detailed work." :)

Kate
13/10/2015 04:21:35 pm

Claire, is there any difference between the PINK T'GAAL and the other colors, do you know? I'm asking because the Pink is priced higher than the others on Amazon.ca and lower than the others on Amazon.com. I'm thinking it's probably just different sellers, but maybe you tried a few colors and know for sure?

Reply
Claire
13/10/2015 05:42:25 pm

Hi Kate, there's no difference at all between colours. Pink is probably the most popular colour and the Amazon algorithm has picked that up and bumped the price on it x

Reply
Kate
13/10/2015 08:29:32 pm

Thanks, Claire! Your guess is probably spot-on. :)

Chrissy link
13/10/2015 10:37:04 pm

I have the first one you listed, the long point one and mine works fabulously! the only complaint I have with it is the case only holds the shavings for about 3 sharpenings. I have been using it with my prismas for several coloring pages now and it's just brilliant and for the price I'm very happy. Did you sharpen it until it got close to the "stop" spot?

Reply
Claire
14/10/2015 04:22:14 pm

I did yes, it just wasn't working for me. I'm thinking the blades were dull, there are some comments about that being the case x

Reply
Danica
6/11/2015 06:27:30 pm

Hi, may I ask what point setting you use on Tgaal Sharpener for Prismacolor?

Reply
Claire
25/7/2017 04:23:44 pm

Hi Danica, I use point 2 or 3

Reply
Tawnya
27/12/2015 07:04:49 am

Thank you,
I found this very interesting,
I have had problems with sharpener,
Have bought 5 so far trying to find the right one.
I really like the TGaal adjustable,

Reply
Sarah
25/7/2017 03:58:15 pm

Hello
I couldn't find any DUX website. Does the company changed name?
Do you have any info on this brand?
thanks a lot

Reply
Claire
25/7/2017 04:23:08 pm

Hi Sarah, I can't find a website for them either, but their sharpeners are sold by many stationery companies & stores.

Reply
Karen
19/10/2017 12:21:36 pm

Thanks so much for this review I was on the fence about a new sharpener, as I colour more and more I am no longer so happy with my prismacolor sharpener, can't get the long points I crave. So I will be looking at this sharpener at Amazon as well, and I like the pink as long as it's not crazy expensive :) Thanks so much for your rewiews very helpful.

Reply
Kim Richmond
22/3/2018 06:22:11 am

About your experience with the KUM sometimes the blade isn’t seated correctly because there is manufacturing residue under the blade which keeps it from seating properly. Take a flat bladed screwdriver and clean that area and replace the blade, you may fall back in love with this wonderful sharpener.

Reply
Kim Richmond
22/3/2018 06:26:20 am

I also find that the wax / oil cores of colored pencils builds up in the blades. I find sharpening a graphite pencil now and then helps clear it off and it will sharpen properly again.

Reply
Cheryl Turtlemoon link
26/3/2018 06:43:31 pm

Brilliant! Really helpful, thanks. I’m off to buy the adjustable one!

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    RSS Feed

    DMCA.com Protection Status
©Claire Eadie 2015
  • ~Home~
  • ~My Story~
  • ~Mental Health~
  • ~Beginner's Guide to Colouring~
  • ~Tutorials~
  • ~Colouring Book Reviews~
  • ~Product Reviews~
  • ~Arts & Crafts Reviews~
  • ~Gallery~
  • ~Colouring Challenges~
  • ~Gemstones~
  • ~Charts~
  • ~Digital Painting~
  • ~Illustrator Interviews~
  • ~Media Appearances~
  • ~FAQ~
  • ~Contact~
  • ~Policy~
  • Palette generator